Google search engine

Counsel for Bernard Antwi Boasiako, popularly known as Chairman Wontumi, Samuel Atta Akyea, has said his client is seeking an out-of-court settlement with the Attorney-General over the criminal case involving EXIM Bank.

He said the defence team believes the case is essentially a civil debt matter and should not necessarily proceed through a full criminal trial if the outstanding debt can be settled.

Speaking on the matter in an interview on TV3’s Daily Brief, Tuesday, November 17, Atta Akyea disclosed that his client had instructed the legal team to pursue a plea bargain arrangement outside the courtroom, under which they will seek the charges to be dropped in exchange for payment of the outstanding amount.

He stressed, however, that the proposed arrangement would not involve Chairman Wontumi pleading guilty to the charges.

“We are of the humble view that this is a civil matter. Do we have to go through the full hall of a criminal trial if we can settle the matter and pay off the debt. This is where we are.

“This is sum of our calculations and he instructed us to go ahead and do a plea bargain. This time around he wants it done outside the court, which is to say he will not plead guilty to the matter.

“So, there is one that you make an arrangement with the Attorney-General, the charges are dropped, the amount is paid and that’s the end of the matter,” he said.

The lawyer explained that the proposed arrangement would involve negotiations with the Attorney-General, the withdrawal of the charges and payment of the amount owed to EXIM Bank.

Atta Akyea also disclosed that the defence had filed a writ seeking a declaration that the case was a civil debt dispute being presented as a criminal matter.

He questioned the basis of the allegations involving allegedly forged documents used to secure the loan.

According to him, if the documents used to secure the loan were indeed forged per the prosecution’s claim, then questions should also be raised about the role of the bank’s officials in processing and approving the loan.

“The complainant is EXIM Bank, if there are criminality then officers of EXIM Bank are complicit because when you present a document for a loan, they will do due diligence.

“So, if you say the documents that were used induced the bank to give the loan were forged documents, you have indicted EXIM Bank,” he added.

He maintained that a failure to repay a loan should not automatically be treated as criminal conduct, insisting that the matter should be resolved through repayment of the debt rather than criminal prosecution.

“I believe that if seriously you want to look at this matter and as I have told you the foundational understanding and to prove that this is not bad faith, a loan default should not be the subject matter of criminality, that is my humble view.

“You need to pay for your loan and when you can’t pay, it does not make you a criminal,” Atta Akyea argued.

Background

It is not the first figure his team has put on the table. In July the state turned down an earlier offer, with Deputy Attorney-General Dr Justice Srem-Sai saying the prosecution was not satisfied with it.

According to the report, the state wanted the full GH¢30 million, plus interest.

The talks began in June, when the court allowed both sides to negotiate a plea bargain. Atta Akyea took over as lead counsel in July and asked for time to finish them.

They failed. In August the Accra High Court ordered the case to go to trial.

Prosecutors then filed a fresh charge sheet in September. Thomas Antwi-Boasiako and Wontumi Farms Limited are charged alongside the former NPP Ashanti Regional Chairman, whose real name is Bernard Antwi-Boasiako.

They face five counts between them: defrauding by false pretences, uttering forged documents (two counts), money laundering, and causing financial loss to a public body.

Prosecutors allege that the two men obtained about GH¢14.3 million from EXIM Bank in 2018 for a farming project by false pretences, and that the bank lost GH¢30 million between 2018 and 2022.

They also allege that a forged receipt was presented to the bank to support an application for a further GH¢4 million.

Wontumi has pleaded not guilty. His lawyers have also asked the court to treat the case as a civil matter, arguing that the collateral and insurance on the loans are enough to pay them off.

He is already serving a 20-year jail term for illegal mining offences linked to Samreboi. On Monday the High Court refused him bail pending his appeal, ruling that the appeal had no likelihood of success.

The Economic and Organised Crime Office is separately seeking to confiscate his assets, including GH¢50 million in Treasury bills.